One particular melody has been residing in my head this period, and it's not, it isn't from the singer's recent album. It comes by a far more refined artist: a children's entertainer. The song is called Big Feelings and its words state: “Big feelings are OK / I’m here to stay with your big feelings.”
The Growth of Strong Emotions On Social Media
Thanks to the trend for gentle parenting, the concept of “big feelings” has transformed into big money on the web, and generally I welcome that. Being a parent, powerful emotions are difficult to avoid: you're having them, the small child in your household is having them and, in one of the most significant departures for us as a species, so are numerous other children on your online platforms.
In fact, videos of infants and children weeping is so widespread on certain platforms that many parents accept it without thought. I don't have TikTok and my Instagram suggestions is primarily centered around soup and witchcraft, but when a friend told me that she found the phenomenon concerning, not to mention unethical, I viewed some of the videos myself.
What I Saw: Kids at Their Most Fragile
What I found was clip after clip of children at their most fragile. Weeping, shouting, screaming, and sometimes becoming aggressive. I have naturally been observant to these instances in my own home, but observing another person's child experiencing it feels profoundly disturbing, particularly when that child is not being comforted by their own parent. Hardest to excuse is a category of video in which mothers expose their children to medical procedures while their little one cries and screams directly to camera. It is important to mention that the majority of the videos are different, and yet there is nevertheless something unsettling about them all.
When Intense Reactions Aren't Distressing
Of course, “big feelings” are not always completely upsetting. When your child is sitting on the sidewalk heartbroken at the understanding that cake isn't infinite it can be hard to remain serious. Many of us have been regaled with tales of especially iconic outbursts of our own. Mine included shouting “GIVE ME ALL YOUR MONEY!” in the entrance of the a modern art venue in the heart of the city. Gently mocking your child about a time they had a meltdown, or sharing a laugh with your partner once they have retired for the night, is one thing. Recording a child in a moment of distress and posting it to the internet for all to see without permission is a separate issue entirely.
Disturbing Phenomena and Humiliation
Then you have the trends that are plainly unpleasant, such as a challenge that featured shocking babies into silence by throwing a processed food at their heads, or cracking an egg on them. This content appears geared towards humiliating children. In an article for the a major publication, an author stated: “The most unsettling part of these videos [is that] the parents are scarcely connecting to their kids. Instead they are responding to a mirror image of their children that they are spreading online. And they are reveling in their authority over that image.”
The Defense of Teachability
There are video creators who would despise such content. They claim that they are filming their children at their most exposed not for entertainment, but because they are aiming to develop learning opportunities – “observe how serenely and beautifully I was able to defuse this child’s meltdown using these methods”. A few even try to avoid inevitable criticism. “This video is posted to inform and increase understanding – not for endorsement or views”, an example, shared by an page operated by a medical professional, apparently states. The declaration that ensues is some of the most self-applauding foolishness I have seen on the online. “If you don’t live the life, avoid judging the moment.”
A Challenge of Duty
What if you avoid posting the moment? I often wonder. Because I certainly critique these people. The impression I get, when I view a video of a little one in distress, whether their parent is performing comfort or not, is a dereliction of duty – the obligation to be attentive for your child. And I ponder what implication it conveys, where when your child begins showing a “big feeling”, you get your phone out. How does that reflect to your young one about their completely normal emotions? “Sharing real moments is part of the learning”, reportedly.
Considerations on Child Development
While my husband and I begin exploring schools for our son, it’s difficult not to think about how strategies to parenting have changed since we were young. There is an increased understanding of the fact that “big feelings” are par for the course for youngsters. These days a lot of adults aim to accept those emotions and offer children a protected setting in which to share their feelings. However despite what the online advisors claim, I do not think you can genuinely provide a protected setting for your child if you are capturing their instances of vulnerability and violating their privacy and self-respect in the procedure. To be frank, I don’t think these people have a lot to teach any of us about upbringing.
A Closing Thought
There are some who will find that extreme, who would recoil from the fact that in certain respects I’d prefer put a cheese slice on my son's head for a giggle than exploit his distress as a educational instance for engagement. But to them I would state this: if “each conduct is communication”, what, specifically, are these parents trying to say?